Most of us have had times when someone makes us feel uneasy for no clear reason. Whether it’s a strange comment, odd behavior, or just a weird vibe, some people have a way of making us feel like something isn’t right. In this article, 10 people share their creepy stories that might make you rethink the people you meet.

The Story:

I was dating a girl who seemed to really like me—maybe too much. One night, she invited me to dinner, saying she had something special planned. When I got there, the table was set for two, but I noticed something strange in the middle—a small jar filled with what looked like teeth.

I asked her about it, and she smiled and said, “Oh, they’re mine. I’ve been collecting them since I was little.” I tried to laugh it off, but then she said, “You know, people say if you keep something from someone, they can never leave you. I think it works with teeth too. I just need one of yours now.”

I left before dessert. But a few weeks later, I found a small envelope in my mailbox. Inside was a tooth that wasn’t mine, with a note that said, “Yours will fit perfectly with the others.” Ever since then, I can’t stop thinking that she’s still trying to complete her perfect collection.